Heartburn or Heart Attack? How to Tell the Difference When Chest Pain Strikes
You're jolted awake at 2 AM with a burning sensation in your chest. Your mind races: Is this just heartburn from that late dinner, or something far more serious? It's a question that sends thousands of people to emergency rooms every year—and for good reason.
GERD (gastroesophageal reflux disease) and heart attacks can produce remarkably similar symptoms, making them difficult to distinguish. While most chest pain turns out to be non-cardiac, the stakes are too high to guess wrong. Understanding the differences—and knowing when to seek emergency care—could save your life.
Why They Feel So Similar
The heart and esophagus share nerve pathways, which is why the brain can have trouble distinguishing between the two sources of pain. Both conditions can cause:
- Chest pain or pressure
- Pain that radiates to the neck, jaw, or arms
- Discomfort after eating
- Symptoms that worsen when lying down
- Nausea
- Shortness of breath
This overlap is why even doctors sometimes need tests to determine the cause of chest pain.
Clues That Suggest GERD
While GERD symptoms vary, certain patterns suggest acid reflux is the culprit:
Burning Quality
GERD pain is typically described as burning rather than pressure or squeezing. It often starts behind the breastbone and moves upward toward the throat.
Timing Related to Eating
Symptoms usually occur:
- Within 30-60 minutes after eating
- After large or fatty meals
- After consuming trigger foods (spicy foods, citrus, tomatoes, chocolate, caffeine, alcohol)
- When lying down shortly after eating
Relief from Antacids
If over-the-counter antacids like Tums, Rolaids, or medications like Pepcid or Prilosec provide relief, GERD is more likely. Heart pain doesn't respond to antacids.
Acid Taste or Regurgitation
A sour or bitter taste in your mouth, or the sensation of food or liquid coming back up, strongly suggests acid reflux.
Worsens with Position
GERD symptoms often worsen when lying flat or bending over, and improve when sitting upright or standing.
History of Reflux
If you've experienced similar episodes before that were diagnosed as GERD, and this feels the same, it's more likely to be reflux.
Warning Signs of a Heart Attack
Certain features are red flags that suggest a cardiac cause:
Pressure, Squeezing, or Tightness
Heart attack pain is often described as pressure, squeezing, fullness, or a heavy weight on the chest—like an elephant sitting on you—rather than burning.
Pain That Spreads
While GERD pain tends to stay in the chest, heart attack pain commonly radiates to:
- The left arm (or both arms)
- The jaw, neck, or throat
- The back, especially between the shoulder blades
- The upper abdomen
Associated Symptoms
Heart attacks often come with additional symptoms:
- Shortness of breath (even without chest pain)
- Cold sweats or clammy skin
- Lightheadedness or dizziness
- Extreme fatigue
- Nausea or vomiting (especially in women)
- A sense of impending doom
Triggered by Exertion
Heart-related chest pain often occurs during or after physical activity, emotional stress, or exertion—not just after eating.
No Relief from Antacids
If antacids don't help, or if relief is only temporary, be more suspicious of a cardiac cause.
Duration and Pattern
Heart attack symptoms typically last more than a few minutes, may come and go, and tend to worsen over time rather than improve.
Questions to Ask Yourself
When chest pain strikes, quickly run through these questions:
- Does this feel like burning or pressure?
- Did I recently eat, and was it a trigger food?
- Am I sweating, dizzy, or short of breath?
- Does the pain spread to my arm, jaw, or back?
- Do antacids help?
- Have I felt this exact sensation before from reflux?
- Was I physically active or stressed when it started?
Your answers can help guide your response—but when in doubt, always err on the side of caution.
When to Call 911
Call 911 immediately if you experience:
- Chest pain or pressure lasting more than a few minutes
- Pain spreading to the arm, jaw, neck, or back
- Chest pain with shortness of breath, sweating, or dizziness
- Sudden, severe chest pain
- Any chest pain if you have known heart disease or risk factors (high blood pressure, high cholesterol, diabetes, smoking, family history)
- A gut feeling that something is seriously wrong
Never drive yourself to the hospital during a potential heart attack. Paramedics can begin treatment immediately and are equipped to handle cardiac emergencies.
The "Better Safe Than Sorry" Rule
Here's the reality: it's impossible to definitively distinguish between GERD and a heart attack based on symptoms alone. Even emergency physicians use EKGs, blood tests, and other diagnostics to make the determination.
If there's any doubt—especially if you have cardiac risk factors, if this feels different from your usual reflux, or if you're experiencing multiple warning signs—seek emergency care.
Being "wrong" and discovering it was just heartburn is far better than the alternative. Emergency room physicians would much rather reassure you than treat a heart attack that's progressed because of delayed care.
Managing GERD to Reduce Confusion
If you have frequent acid reflux, getting it under control reduces both your discomfort and the anxiety of wondering whether chest pain is serious:
- Avoid eating within 3 hours of bedtime
- Elevate the head of your bed 6-8 inches
- Identify and avoid your trigger foods
- Maintain a healthy weight
- Don't smoke
- Limit alcohol
- Discuss medication options with your doctor
The Bottom Line
Chest pain is always worth taking seriously. While GERD is far more common than heart attacks, the symptoms overlap enough that distinguishing between them isn't always straightforward. Know the warning signs, trust your instincts, and never hesitate to seek emergency care when chest pain feels wrong.
If you're experiencing frequent heartburn or chest pain that concerns you, schedule an appointment. We can evaluate your symptoms, assess your cardiac risk factors, and develop a plan to address both your digestive health and your peace of mind.
